نقدنویس

Beejay Silcox, The Guardian (UK)

۷ نقد در چونی · صفحه‌اش در منبع

In Vigil, the spectral shenanigans are starting to feel like a gimmick: the polyphonic jibber-jabber, the Beckettian riddling, the poo and fart jokes (Saunders loves a bawdy, gassy ghost; a pile of phantom faeces). What once felt anarchic has hardened into habit; a repertoire of tricks and tics. They’re being used to stage a lesson for us – and it grates, to be trapped in someone else’s morality play.

RT

Is there such a thing as too perfect? Enter Whistler, Patchett’s new novel ... The past is held up and examined like a snow globe, given a pretty little shake. But what matters is the perpetual, beautiful now ... Whistler is top-shelf comfort food, the literary equivalent of pricey ice-cream. We almost care about these vanilla-bean people. Their floral arrangements; their silk blouses; their dinky sailboats. But it’s all so neat ... Often reads like a gratitude journal.

RT

Homebound is sentimental, soft-hearted and guileless – the adjectives critics tend to use sneeringly, as though kindness were easy. It’s the sort of book that might have kept my younger self company. I’m glad this generation will have it.

RT

An infernal twist on the campus farce ... Kuang isn’t subtle. She doesn’t allude; she indicts ... This is a novel that believes in ideas – just not the cages we build for them ... Far from perfect ... But none of that really matters – especially if you have a score to settle.

RT

یه ملودرام ۵۰۰ صفحه‌ای از وفاداری والدین و بکوب‌های کوانتومی. تصور کن اورفیوس و اوریدیسه با اینتراستلار، ولی با تام هэнکس از بیگ در نقش اصلی... خیلی از دنیای‌های متخیل بی‌معنن، و به شکلی باشکوه. مشکل اینه که بنجامین مدام توجه ما رو به ماشین‌آلات رواییِ پوسیده‌ش می‌کشه. به سوالاتی جواب می‌ده که اصلا به فکر پرسیدنشون نیومده بودیم... به نظر می‌رسه مطمئن نیست پیش‌فرض کهنسی‌ش بتونه اسرار خودش رو تحمل کنه. اما هرچه بیشتر می‌دونیم، بیشتر حواس‌مون پرت می‌شه... بخشی از مشکل طولشه. زندگی معکوس یه ترفنده، یه آزمایش فکری. کتاب‌هایی که این کار رو به خوبی انجام می‌دن، طنزآمیزن، برنده و کوتاه‌ان.

RT

Domestically sprawling, geopolitically bold ... Delivers a comparable jolt – a truth-rattling rupture. We feel it building with a cruel inevitability, and when it arrives, it shifts the novel’s moral (and political) terrain. To spoil the reveal would be churlish. The question is whether the novel can withstand the shock. It can – just. Choi is one of contemporary literature’s great demolition artists, and her emotional foundations hold. She can build as well as she detonates. Choi gives her cast the room they need to live; to be more than vessels for political wrangling.

RT

Little mirth or mercy ... Feels antiquated ... McGuire’s men are granted room to ponder grand questions of faith, honour and ambition, how far a conscience can be bent; his women fret about marital harmony and tend to the fire ... Heavy on research, light on imagination ... Bleak and bloody ... A hyper-masculine melodrama, fuelled by grievance and petty tyrannies. If only he had something – anything – interesting to say about women.

RT