Riley’s work recasts our relationship with the familiar, transforming ordinary, unremarkable lives of her characters into something startling and new ... Riley’s disquieting acuity and her spare and unsparing prose makes them shimmer with tension. She has a phenomenal ear for dialogue, for the myriad ways in which people unknowingly lay themselves bare, both in what they say and, more agonisingly, in what they don’t – or can’t. She is the laureate of disconnection, her bone-dry humour edged with the vertiginous lurch of despair ... A slim, impeccably controlled story that contains multitudes.
Blisteringly good ... Kennedy...evokes the 1980s city with almost hallucinogenic precision, but her greater power lies in her remarkable humanity. Her characters are messy, flawed, often shatteringly self-destructive but, mapped with her fierce compassion, they march straight off the page ... A love story, a furious, tender, potty-mouthed paean to loyalty and generosity of spirit. It is also an elegy to a generation of lost Irish boys, a heartbreaking testament to the violence and fear passed down from father to son ... Kennedy’s novel is too subtle and clear-eyed to offer easy answers, but her questions will burn themselves into your heart.
Strikingly assured ... Knapp’s plotting is skilful, her tapestry of stories cleverly woven ... Stands out as a compelling and original debut, a book that asks at least as many questions as it answers.
Moves at a propulsive lick, its bloody meat marbled with cruelty and violence ... Inside his characters’ heads, however, McGuire moves with less confidence. Backstories provide context but little complexity or depth ... By emphasising commonalities, in scrupulously eradicating deep cultural difference, McGuire diminishes the power of the four Dene guides to transform the narrative and begs the very question he sought to duck about whether their story was really ever his to tell.
The early parts of the novel are a vividly immersive delight ... As the years pass, though, the book loses some of its early momentum. Novels like David Nicholls’s One Day may make it look easy, but a satisfying narrative that contains itself to only a handful of days is extremely hard to pull off.
در بهترین حالت شگفتانگیز کاسک—که تو این کتاب هم به مقدار قابل توجهی حس میشه—ایدههاش مثل مشت یا رازهای ناخوشایندی که به گوشمون زمزمه میشن، میکوبن... «Life of M» با هوش سرسختی رانده میشه و با مهارت فنی استثنایی شکل گرفته؛ تو اوجش آدم رو تکون میده، اما حس کلی که میذاره، حس جدایی و حتی حقارت است... کتابی که میشه به شدت تحسینش کرد، اما نه کتابی که بتونی دوستش داشته باشی.