نقدنویس

Helen Cullen, The Irish Times (IRE)

۶ نقد در چونی · صفحه‌اش در منبع

خوندن آثار الیزابت استراوت مثل یه گپ‌وگفت صمیمانه با یه قصه‌گوی ماهره که باعث می‌شه دنیا رو از یه زاویه جدید ببینی. اما همین نقطه قوت، یعنی اون لحن نویسندگی خیلی قدرتمندش، اینجا دیگه داره کم‌کم اثرش رو از دست می‌ده... اگه کسی تا حالا نوشته‌های استراوت رو نخونده، این کتاب اصلاً گزینه مناسبی برای شروع نیست. ولی برای اونایی که عاشق نثر ظریف و عمیقش هستن، این اثر یه بازگشت دلپذیر از یه صدای آشناست که این‌بار قصه‌ی جدیدی برای تعریف کردن داره.

RT

As has been the case for Patchett’s most recent novels, this work offers a clear-eyed account of familial evolution over the decades of a lifetime. There is a refreshing no-nonsense energy to Patchett’s prose that enables her to excavate the depths of human emotion without ever becoming sentimental ... As such a charismatic storyteller, her novels are great company. Ultimately Whistler itself is a testament to the transformative power of storytelling, where no stories carry more weight than those we tell ourselves, about who we are and where we came from.

RT

The fact that Stuart has set his third novel on a windswept croft in a Hebridean island community is an exciting development ... Stuart capitalises on all these rich possibilities, but also maximises their potency by placing the novel in a setting so vibrant, textured and alive that the reader is fully transported ... As a powerful further perspective on Scottish masculinity, John of John is less a return to form but rather an evolution. A masterly storyteller with a poet’s prose, this is Stuart’s best yet.

RT

The prose is hypnotic but also full of a surprising narrative tension ... There are times, however, when the spell is broken by jarring shifts in perspective ... Overall, however, Cline does a remarkable job of articulating a fractured human consciousness that humanises beautifully both the alienating mystery of dementia and an often-polarising debate. Longlisted for the Booker Prize, this is a worthy candidate for the win.

RT

Riley has long enjoyed critical acclaim for her particular style of novel: unflinching, keenly observed portrayals of contemporary British life, narrated by complicated women who inhabit difficult relationships with their usually somewhat less sophisticated mothers. Nobody does it better. Riley’s novels are slight, but strong. Completely devoid of sentimentality but rich in human truth. Her seventh offering, The Palm House, follows form ... This novel can be read in one sitting; it is so engaging that it proves impossible not to. Readers don’t turn to Riley for elaborate plots. Instead, what she offers has much higher stakes: how do we navigate and survive ordinary lives? Finding beauty in the banality of everyday human suffering is what typically elevates her work to something extraordinary. In this incarnation, however, her pristine prose soars.

RT

Skilful satire...nuanced precision ... A particular skill of Brown is her ability to write with a cool objectivity a spectrum of characters across class divides and varying ideologies who are all, for the most part, multidimensional, complex creations ... [Brown] is unflinching in a particularly illuminating social analysis that sustains a clear-eyed appraisal... and...is confident in her ability to offer readers both enlightenment and entertainment ... With Universality, Brown more than delivers on her promise.

RT