نقدنویس

Johanna Thomas-Corr

۹ نقد در چونی · صفحه‌اش در منبع

اولین اثر داستانی درخشان درباره دوران ریاست‌جمهوری ترامپ... استراوت شکاف‌های ملی رو نه به شکل شعارهای انتزاعی، بلکه به عنوان تجربه‌ای ملموس و شخصی می‌بینه؛ تجربه‌ای که توی ازدواج‌ها، دوستی‌ها، خانواده‌ها و سکوت‌های دردناک بین آدم‌ها جاریه... این رمان عمیقاً وجودیه و روی موضوعاتی مثل پنهان‌کاری، تنهایی و مرزهای درک متمرکز شده. استراوت توی بیرون کشیدن چیزهایی که زیر پوست زندگی روزمره مخفی شدن، استاده... به نظر می‌رسه این تلخ‌ترین و تکان‌دهنده‌ترین رمان استراوت تا به امروز باشه؛ داستانی که آروم پیش می‌ره، لحنی سوگوارانه داره و با وجود لایه‌های مختلف ایده‌ها و نمادهاش، در ظاهر ساده به نظر می‌رسه.

RT

A work overspilling with vitality ... An unashamedly emotional novel, one with real heart. Stuart is particularly good at conjuring up the thumping agony of rejection, as well as the giddy relief of forgiveness and love ... Unflinching ... At times, the ambitious scale of the novel and its many narrative threads mean you lose a sense of Cal’s emotional development ... Achieves a deft balance between detail and drama, sadness and comedy ... Few contemporary novelists produce prose so vivid, generous and full-bodied. I suspect John of John will resonate profoundly with readers — and it is difficult to imagine this year’s Booker shortlist without it.

RT

The book meanders quite pleasantly for a couple of hundred pages ... This is where the novel ought to come alive. Instead it loses its nerve ... Mason’s prose is lightly ironic, full of playful narrative sleights of hand. But where in North Woods the mosaic of voices over centuries gradually resolves into a satisfying whole, here the fragments never quite cohere.

RT

A defining novel about assisted dying ... Emotionally expansive and mature ... A magnificent high-wire book that turns a personal crisis into a reckoning with modern life ... 'Unflinching' is one of the most overused words in criticism, but here it is entirely appropriate. There’s something very brave about how Cline sees her premise through to its painful, inevitable end.

RT

A triumph of non-sentimental nostalgia ... Acute ... Riley’s novels draw their energy from tense relationships and cringeworthy encounters, depicted with pitiless clarity. Her instinct is to probe the fault lines between the comic and the horrific ... A reflective melancholy gathers almost by stealth, settling in the spaces between sentences.

RT

A triumph of deadpan comedy ... Kennard is superb at capturing the chaotic interior life that produces such thoughts. The narrator’s mind is an elaborate ecosystem of digressions — riffs on everything from Henry James’s horny characters to the video game Animal Crossing ... Surreal and ambitious ... But beneath the playfulness lies a thoughtful, tender meditation on the difficulty of being a man in the modern world ... A brilliant comic tour de force.

RT

NDiaye’s story moves with unnerving ease between realism and the fantastical ... Throughout the book you keep expecting Lucie’s powers (weak though they are) to offer a route out of her bleak circumstances — there must be spells, surely, for bad marriages, for disappointing parents — but NDiaye withholds such satisfactions. Magic here is neither glamorous nor that effective. It’s often beside the point. Instead, the novel becomes an uncanny exploration of motherhood and disappointment, and of the uneasy inheritance passed between parents and children ... The effect is faintly Kafkaesque; everything is legible yet nothing quite makes sense ... The Witch lingers ... If television trains us to expect coherence and the comfort of recognition, The Witch denies it.

RT

For a writer who claims to have dispensed with plot, character and cheap dramatic devices, Rachel Cusk has given us one hell of a soap opera ... The ultimate high-concept collaboration, a kind of Dior-styled Alien vs Predator with a side order of Parisian angst. Either that or a desperate gimmick ... The opening chapters are among the novel’s strongest ... However, the air begins to leak out. We are given a lot of granular detail about surfaces — clothes, interiors, architecture, optimised bodies — but almost nothing about the messy business of loving, parenting, quarrelling or desiring ... This points to what increasingly feels like the central limitation of Cusk’s project. She has spent the past decade stripping away what she regarded as the contrivances of the realist novel — plot, character, explanatory psychology — only to replace them with contrivances of her own: unnamed narrators, shifting pronouns, coy withholding and characters who refuse to disclose information they already possess. These devices once created exhilarating ambiguity. Here they feel like mannerisms masquerading as profundity.

RT

It takes a while to orient yourself ... The novel never settles into a predictable shape, switching tantalisingly between family members, first and third-person narration, past and present tense. It’s a bit disorientating, but that’s the beauty of this spellbinding story about a group of people navigating a period of upheaval ... It’s a book that reveals Aw’s greatest strength as a novelist — an ability to subtly shift and unsettle your perceptions of characters and situations. The South deliberately resists easy resolutions. We must wait — and enjoy waiting.

RT