نقدنویس

John Boyne, Irish Times (IRE)

۶ نقد در چونی · صفحه‌اش در منبع

Ebbott digs deep into the psyches of both men but a strong premise suffers from the novel’s lack of narrative development. It might be deliberate, but both couples are so alike that it becomes difficult to tell them apart ... Ebbott can certainly write—there’s a depth to his paragraphs that demands the reader’s careful attention—but it all feels a little old-fashioned, recalling those dead giants while giving a sense that Among Friends would have been a footnote in their bibliographies.

RT

There’s more than enough here to show [Lin's] skill as a writer ... What makes Deep House so engaging, however, is how its author avoids outrage while recounting past injustices. Instead, knowing that the argument has already been won, both morally and legally, he seems baffled that anyone ever cared who married whom in the first place. When future generations look back and wonder what all the fuss was about, books such as this will illuminate their understanding of a time when bigotry was not only encouraged, but on the statute books.

RT

نیمه‌راه رمان اولین اثر T Kira Madden، یک گربه تو صحنه میاد و اگر دقت کنید می‌بینید اسمش Patricia هست، که یه اشاره به Patricia Highsmith است… طبیعتاً چند پیچ‌وخم میاد، اما از نوع «ممکنه اما بعید» هستن و اون حل‌و‌فصل هوشمندانه‌ی آثار Highsmith رو ندارن. با این حال، Whidbey جذابیت خاصی داره که صفحه‌ورق‌ها رو می‌چرخونه و می‌تونه یک سرگرمی خوب برای تعطیلات باشه. فقط وقتی می‌خونی، با غریبه‌ها حرف نزن.

RT

Continuing the story into 1965 and, finally, 1999 provides a neat structure, Hunter offering a single day in Ivy’s life each time ... Alan Hollinghurst’s The Stranger’s Child and Michael Cunningham’s The Hours are novels that repeatedly came to my mind as I was reading, for the language employed, the character traits, the time slips, and the deeply interior and sensitive perceptions are common to all. But there’s something a little calculated about the writing here that makes it feel like an exercise in style rather than a work of authentic fiction ... Eventually, every novelist must decide the type of writer they want to be: someone who mimics successful formulae or hopes to create their own. For all of Megan Hunter’s obvious talent, I wonder if it’s time for her to make that choice.

RT

رمان «Fair Play» (غیر‑داستانی، ۲۰۲۵) ترکیبی از معمای قتل در یک عمارت روستایی سرگرم‌کننده و بررسی عمیق غم و اندوه است… با این که از همان ابتدا تعداد نسبتاً زیادی شخصیت معرفی می‌شه، واقعا تحت تأثیر قرار گرفتم از این‌که لوئیس هگارتی هر کدوم رو چقدر متمایز می‌کنه… این ترکیب باعث می‌شه کتابی با شوخ‌طبعی بالا داشته باشیم، اما هگارتی سعی در تمسخر سنت‌ها نداره، بلکه در حال تجلیل ازشون هست… من حاضرم تو این بازی بین معمای سبک و صحنه‌های تاریک‌تر معاصر شرکت کنم، اما هگارتی روی لبهٔ نازکی قدم می‌زنه بین بامزه و گیج‌کننده…

RT

The premise is brilliant ... Extraordinary ... A powerful read, although there were a few moments that might have been excised ... Timely.

RT