نقدنویس

Mei Chin, The Irish Times (IRE)

۳ نقد در چونی · صفحه‌اش در منبع

شگفت‌انگیزه … حتی اگه تو دل‌ت حس کنی که داستانش خوش‌پایان نیست، خوندن Good People یه حس سرشار از هیجان می‌ده.

RT

A profoundly earnest, funny, and sexy read, one that wears its considerably-sized heart on its sleeve ... Characters are more vivid than life, their heroic qualities and flaws ablaze ... Visual art is notoriously difficult to articulate, but Eggers has not only done it, he’s also coupled it with the other impossible-to-express thing that is pure, unabashed feeling. The result fills us with wonder.

RT

The weakness of Workhorse is its length, taking a third of its 560 pages to introduce a twist that assures you it’s darker than other strappy-sandal tales. Numerous plots sag, losing their deviousness and dread ... There’s still much to be enjoyed ... However, Workhorse is about the pursuit of perfection, and so to appreciate it is to also wish that it itself was more winnowed. With luck, the next book Palmer writes will be a trifle more svelte.

RT