همدلی عمیق الیزابت استراوت و دقت وسواسگونهاش به جزئیات رفتار و روانشناسی انسان، مثل همیشه کاملاً مشهود است... اما با این حال، این کتاب تا به اینجا تاریکترین اثر اوست؛ غرق در سیاهیِ بیپایانی که هم شخصیت اصلی را در بر میگیرد و هم به خواننده سرایت میکند... بعضی جاها بیش از حد مستقیم و اغراقآمیز است و دقیقاً همین موضوع باعث شده این اثر یکی از ضعیفترین کارهای داستانی استراوت باشد؛ نه به خاطر اینکه تحلیلهایش دقت کمتری دارد، بلکه چون انگار داستان در مسیر تبدیل شدن به یک تمثیل یا استعاره، مسیرش را گم کرده است... خیلی از اتفاقات رمان با یک بدیهی بودنِ آزاردهنده، مستقیم به رگ خواننده تزریق شده... این فضای غمبار نه تنها بیامان است، بلکه انگار از روی برنامه پیش میرود... من به عنوان یکی از پر و پاقرصترین طرفداران منتقد الیزابت استراوت، اصلاً خوشحال نمیشوم که بپرسم: پس آن طنز گزنده، چرخشهای داستانی غافلگیرکننده، شور و هیجان و بینش نافذ، و آن غم تکاندهنده و تعابیر شاعرانه و دقیق کجا رفتهاند؟... با این همه، هنوز هم پیامها و لحظات معنادار زیادی در این رمان پیدا میشود.
A rare phenomenon in contemporary fiction: a novel both majestic and intimate, original and masterful in its structure, crystalline in its prose, revelatory in its insights, utterly devastating yet ultimately uplifting in its emotional impact. It is a radiantly intelligent and emotionally wrenching page-turner, the exquisite production of an author working at the height of her powers. I think it is her best novel yet ... It is a truly magnificent achievement.
An aptly titled collection that wallops its reader with ferocious honesty and searing emotional force even as it demonstrates artistic delicacy, intellectual subtlety, and ethical nuance.
Over time, Russo’s work has become less uproariously funny and more ruminative. In his Washington Post review of 2023’s Somebody’s Fool, Ron Charles, one of our best critics of fiction, wrote that Russo 'has become our national priest of masculine despair and redemption.' The new novel, Under the Falls, is a would-be sermon from this vein of prophecy ... Despite its conventional materials and approach, Under The Falls is insightful and well-written. Sentences unfurl smoothly and the setting is evocatively rendered. A crisp present tense third person voice carries us along ... But the novel bored me and ultimately left me cold. Under The Falls is one of Russo’s shortest books and yet it doesn’t move swiftly or suspensefully to its conclusion. The mystery isn’t very mysterious. The secrets are obvious from early on; in an unfortunate kind of dramatic irony, the reader is waiting for the characters to catch up. Those characters never compelled my interest, and I never felt moved by their plights ... a minor, inoffensive addition to the illustrious Russo canon.
A vision of the future both deeply disconcerting and oddly exhilarating ... Not a simple condemnation of technological advancement, an exercise in Luddite nostalgia, or a screed about the perils of innovation ... After the uncanny and vibrantly imagined world of Ply, after the fresh and vital voice of the pincher, the novel’s second half felt disappointing and the playing with pronouns and tenses a bit gimmicky. Yet pleasures still appear ... A testament to the surpassing importance of the human voice, artistic fecundity, improvisation, and ingenuity.