نقدنویس

Rennmora

۳ نقد در چونی · ۲ توصیه، ۱ عدم توصیه · همه‌ی نقدهایش در Steam

Librarian: Tidy Up the Arcane Library! توصیه می‌کند

یه جوری شد که قبل از خرید و بازی کردن، متوجه اون بخش مربوط به استفاده از هوش مصنوعی نشدم و واقعاً حیف شد؛ چون اصلاً هیچ نیازی نبود که از تصاویر ساخته شده با هوش مصنوعی تو این بازی استفاده کنن. بعد از اینکه اون متن رو خوندم، عملاً مجبور شدم دنبالشون بگردم تا پیداشون کنم. این تصاویر هیچ ارزشی به بازی اضافه نکردن، ولی دقیقاً به همین دلیل می‌دونم خیلیا بازی رو نمی‌خرن. با این حال، به جز این مورد، بازی فوق‌العاده‌ست.

۷۲۸ نفر مفید دانستند Steam
دیسپچ توصیه می‌کند ۸٫۶ ساعت بازی

The worst thing about this game is that at some points you run out of game and then there’s no more game. I need more. Of everything. The dispatch game, the office dynamics, the stupid jokes. Please! For the actual review, the game is wonderful. Visually - both the artstyle, animations and the way the scenes are presented and edited is absolute cinema. The soundtrack slaps as well, perfectly fits the moods of the scenes. Narratively - I enjoyed every single character and the way they interact with one another, the squabbles, the jokes and the wholesome moments. There is a dispatch management game that was so fun I would love that as a standalone game. Enough reading, go play now.

۳۵۴ نفر مفید دانستند Steam
داستان‌های شایر: ارباب حلقه‌ها توصیه نمی‌کند ۱۸٫۴ ساعت بازی

TLDR: I have mixed feelings about this game, sadly most of them are negative. Now for the essay. I feel like I had some unrealistic expectations set for this game, whether it was from the youtube/tiktok videos or something I saw on social media, I assumed this would be an evolved, life sim game with a long play time. That is why my initial impression was worse than it should’ve been. Don’t get me wrong the performance of this game was atrocious and it should’ve NEVER been released like this, even with the patch, there are still stutters. But I will be putting aside the expectations of the game and trying to see it for what it is rather than what I was lead to believe in the marketing. This is not a HORRIBLE game, but unfortunately, it is not GOOD either. I need Steam to implement “LUKEWARM” option for reviews. Right at the start you are to make your hobbit and personally, I felt many of the customizations were just laughable, if you are trying to make a cute hobbit, you have only a very few choices. That said the clothes, both the starter and the ones you can purchase later on are very cute. While the hobbit models could use some extra love, the environment is absolutely wonderful, beautiful sights all around, the changing of seasons was also a treat to see. Here I would like to mention a great thing the devs cooked - following the birds. To get to the next goal, or a place of your choosing, you just need to follow the birds that will sit on strategically placed environmental markers. This was amazing, made me pay more attention to the surroundings and taught me how to make way through the forests without always looking at the map. The main gameplay loop will be gathering, gardening and cooking so I shall speak about each separately. - Gathering is nice at the start, though it will soon turn into a grind. To level up this skill you will get little quests, where you will be asked to gather certain amount of a reagent, it will likely take you multiple days to get all of them and later when the quest asks for a higher quality, it might even take you a whole season like it did me. You can only have 10 of them active at a time so each day you end up going to the same places, hoping you’ll get luck with the high quality proc. - Fishing was a nice change of pace, the minigame was something I have not seen before and quite enjoyable, but ultimately will result in the same grind game as gathering. - Gardening was nice with the introduction of crop relations - if you plant certain crops together it will increase their quality. Love that. - The cooking minigame was interesting, especially later when more tools get unlocked and you can experiment with seasonings and how much you can adjust the flavours. At the start, however it might be a bit frustrating. You will need to cook meals for your fellow hobbit villagers, but be careful, if you won’t invite one of them for some time, they will get angry (entitled little shi-), so keep in mind to rotate your guests :) As for the character relationships, there are some small things you get to uncover about each of them, but it is very short, a few sentence intermission, if you will. The friendships unlock more things than quests, you get rewards in form of recipes, items or even further upgrades to your hobbit… molehill… whatever it is called. There is a story going on the background, very simple, which also explains the lack of voice acting. While it was surprising at first, I don’t think the story would benefit TOO much from it so I won’t hold that against the game, especially with the price point it is being sold at. I will reiterate again that this is a small game in scope, therefore the map you are running around and doing everything on, is also very small. There will be different things to collect during each of the seasons, but you will absolutely be still running on the same few paths over and over. I would say the one thing this game did spectacularly would be the house customization and decoration. There are very many items to collect, be it from vendor or from the characters, you get house expansion, even garden decorations. So here, my final thoughts. The game is REALLY slow at the start, if you are expecting a big scale game, pass on this, if you are expecting intricate story and interesting character friendships, pass again. If the game looks interesting to you and you don’t mind a VERY slow paced, relaxing and a little grindy experience, go for it, but I would still wait for a sale. I honestly can’t really recommend this with clear conscious at the full price, even if it is not that steep.

۲۲۰ نفر مفید دانستند Steam