Houman Barekat, The Guardian (UK)

  • ۴ نقد در چونی
صفحه‌اش در منبع
روت
دوگانه

As much as we get by way of overarching narrative: not so much an arc as a flat line. In the most enjoyable plotless novels, the rhythms of inner life generate a momentum that substitutes for action. Here, Ruth’s diffident consciousness is a halting, intermittent presence ... Yet although the novel sometimes drags, Riley’s droll, sardonic narrative voice keeps the reader on board.

امپراتوری نخبگان
مثبت

یک کار سرد و بی‌تکلف—روایتی منظم و به‌صورت زمان‌بندی‌شده از نیم‌قرن رفت‌وآمد—ولی مزیتش اینه که نسبتاً عینیه. Empire of the Elite یک مقدمه واضح به این دنیای نادر و آدمایی که توش زندگی می‌کردن.

زندگی ام
مثبت

The clever paradox of this novel is that it is actually a commentary on Cusk’s métier ... The fictional biographer is winging it, and admits as much when M takes issue with her unflattering portrayal in these pages. This device affords Cusk some moral and creative leeway, but it feels contrived and pat ... Therein lies the rub. Suffering is indeed a currency in our trauma-obsessed cultural landscape. Friends, lovers, parents, children: all can be traded in for cash, kudos or just attention, provided you can live with the emotional consequences.

کانترپاستو
دوگانه

Rob, known as Cricket to his friends, is just nine years old when he meets Olympia ... He is instantly smitten by the force of her personality ... Over the next six decades, they intermittently drift in and out of each other’s lives ... The novel’s only motive force is time itself: as the years tumble by, Cricket is ever on hand to comfort Olympia amid her various life struggles – addiction issues, divorce, illness – with a martyr’s devotion. His constancy is admirable, and depressing ... This appeal to unpretentious decency panders to the prejudices of the middlebrow reader. Conveniently, it doubles as a defence of Eggers’s fiction – of the cosy, lulling cadences of his prose, which feels redolent of children’s fables even when dealing with adult themes; of the saccharine, fortune-cookie sentimentalism in his evocation of modest contentment.