مدلین کش دنیای موازی لاست لمبز رو با یه نثر زنده و روان که با شوخیهای هوشمندانه و یه رنگه، ترسیم کرده... هرچند به نظر میرسه کتاب همیشه نمیدونه دقیقاً چقدر باید با خودش جدی باشه... اما کش با اون نثر پرانرژی و تخیل بیقرارش، فراتر از یه توصیف ساده از این دنیا رفته؛ اون عملاً این دنیا رو از نو خلق کرده.
Continues some ways down the path of developing, or at least exhibiting, her themes of brutality, entropy, and disgust for humankind ... The Vivisectors still feels unhelpfully caught in the crosshairs of the internet, and not only because of the many trollish remarks that appear in its pages. One of the narrator’s complaints about literature is 'that books had emptied along with the world that contained them because now almost everything that mattered to us took place inside our devices, on the abstract territories of the internet.' Is The Vivisectors disparaging this sort of 'emptied' novel, or attempting to give it newfound spiritual relevance? I tend to think it’s the latter. Either way, abstraction wins out.
Ambitious ... It’s curious, then—given Ruth ’s fascinating setting and provenance—how little the book has to say about community or faith ... What is most surprising of all is that this novel seems in large part to be about desserts ... There is no plot holding the novel together ... Whether by destiny or by design, Ruth tests the hypothesis that style can be everything, that style can be God ... Ruth ’s polish can be one of its pleasures, but Riley is often willing to sacrifice clarity and mood for the sake of a shiny word or a grandiose turn of phrase ... It is Ruth alone who anchors the book in any consistent feeling ... After a while, though, the lack of conflict in her world becomes glaring ... The reader’s yearning for 'something powerful' is never extinguished.