Catherine Taylor, The Guardian (UK)

  • ۵ نقد در چونی
صفحه‌اش در منبع
مفتون
مثبت

Its high-wire plot and uneven trajectory make for a relentlessly dizzying experience ... The unrolling suspense compels, as does the deep dive into both characters and their motives ... While Hooked wears its aura of black comedy lightly, and its political statements more heavily, there are weirdly farcical aspects, such as a wildly contrived subplot in which a popular office temp turns out to be a psychopath. The most interesting takeaway from Hooked is that it doesn’t wallow in easy answers. And the finale, when it eventually arrives, tones down the manic drama to end on a quiet, even philosophical note.

کتاب رکوردها
ستایش

At first this somewhat whimsical framing is frustrating — what is the deeper link between Lina, her father and these voices from history? As the novel proceeds, their correlation becomes clearer and Thien plunges the reader into thrilling, perilous leaps back and forth across time. Her rendering of the bustling commerce of Spinoza’s Amsterdam is exquisite ... Thien’s inhabiting of these different timescales is a marvel of research and imagination. At times it takes on a surreal aspect: in one passage featuring Arendt, a poem by Du Fu appears on the reverse of the paper she threads through the communal typewriter of a boarding house in Lisbon ... Thien’s dazzling historical somersault doubles as a plea for humanity.

چراغ قوه
ستایش

Susan Choi’s sixth novel takes a little-known and appalling aspect of Japanese-Korean history and fashions it into a rich generational saga that teems with intelligence, curiosity and, in terms of reading, sheer pleasure. Like the flashlight of its title it casts an evasive, variably illuminating beam, focusing on the hidden lives of characters, their careless and destructive lies, random yet weighted connections to each other, vulnerability and extraordinary ability to survive ... A restless, leisurely and capacious work of such emotional force and controlled style that it surely cannot be overlooked by this year’s Booker judges.

عمومیت
دوگانه

The narratives created here are deliciously nasty and brutish ... Universality is an uncomfortable, sharp and funny satire on Britain today, including a particularly acute takedown of the media and publishing industries ... Yet for all its cleverness, it can seem as hollow and one-dimensional as the characters it derides ... As a send-up of the culture wars, Universality succumbs to the very pitfalls Amis warned against.

ما تکه‌های زیبا و گوشتی
ستایش

قاطع، هیجان‌انگیز … هم پر سر و صدا و هم تاریک، هم زندگی‌بخش و هم زندگی‌نقض‌کننده، هم آشنا و در عین حال کاملاً نو. احساس می‌کنی که ضروریه. احتمالاً تو این سال چیز دیگه‌ای شبیه به این پیدا نمی‌کنی … متفکرانه و بازنگری‌گر، به شدت تند و تلخ … زبان براون شعرآمیز و ریتمیکه، جسمانی و متمایزه … متن سنگینیه، ولی تو دست براون این محتوا به‌طریقی سبک می‌شه.