Dwight Garner, The New York Times Book Review

  • ۱۰ نقد در چونی
صفحه‌اش در منبع
نگهبانی
منفی

Saunders’s new novel, Vigil, is slim, about the size of Mitch Albom’s memoir Tuesdays with Morrie or Richard Bach’s novella Jonathan Livingston Seagull. It’s not as soft and shallow and saccharine and strenuously earnest as those books, but it’s not impossibly far off. It’s a hot-water bottle in print form. It’s going to be an enormous best seller for depressing reasons.

روت
دوگانه

There are inklings of greatness ... It isn’t easy of access and won’t be to everyone’s taste ... Defiantly strange ... I respect this novel enough to say this in criticism: The reader waits for a second act, for a deepening or a new chord to appear, and it never quite does. Ruth begins to flatten about two-thirds of the way through. You end this novel swimming in the same water you entered ... Is in touch with the oldest and darkest things in our makeup, yet revels in a very modern sense of what Riley calls 'brainy female despair.'

ناپدیدشدگان
ستایش

A maximalist’s banquet: It is humane, blood-flecked, disturbing and sustaining ... James has written a masterpiece, the novel of the decade and possibly of the century thus far ... One of the signal reading experiences of my adult life. It sank knives deep into my heart. I’m still in recovery from it.

سه روز در ژوئن
دوگانه

This is not Tyler’s best novel, nor is it her worst, though it’s closer to the bottom than to the top ... Three Days in June is the sort of novel in which characters get pretty excited about microwaving a pair of potpies ... The pages did not turn themselves, but it is good enough that I did not resent my fingers for doing the job.

وقتی اوضاع خوب بود
مثبت

Carter’s book will make some readers itchy. I quickly and (mostly) happily consumed it anyway. The journalism stories and the character analysis, as Elizabeth Hardwick liked to call gossip, are first-rate ... The prose is basic ... Carter is not one for introspection ... There is not a great deal about Carter’s marriages (three) or children (five) in this memoir. He is proud that he reserved his evenings for them, he says. He does not attempt to reconcile this comment with the fact that, being a varsity socializer, he appears to be out every night. Such are the contradictions of being Graydon Carter, homme du monde

در آن سوی دیگر می‌بینمت
منفی

احساسی و نیمه‌خودزندگی‌نامه‌ای … جوششش تقریباً تمام شده … یک دو لحظه طول می‌کشه تا یکی دیگه از نشانه‌های خاص مک‌اینِرنی به چشم بیاد. وقتی این کار می‌کنه، تعادل رمان رو حتی بیشتر از دیالوگ‌های چوبی و توضیحی و نظرات سطحی و شفاف درباره نیویورک، همپتونز و ازدواج به‌هم می‌ریزه … یک سیل بی‌پرده از مصرف نمایشی … این باعث شد که به‌قدری از این رمان متنفر شم که دل‌م شکست.

لایه
منفی

Diaz’s characters lack interiority. They’re action figures, posed into series of cinematic stances ... As humorless as a James Blunt song ... Little interest is taken in the messy, earthy life that humans make do with. Diaz doesn’t do close-up work ... Ply wears its politics, gender and otherwise, very heavily ... As clunky and didactic, in a progressive-anarchist direction, as anything in Ayn Rand’s The Fountainhead. For readers of nearly any politics, it’s suffocating, as if someone has thrown a tarp over your head.

چراغ قوه
مثبت

Ambitious ... Choi has set out to shine a flashlight, if you will, on a series of historical wrongs, the worst of them committed by North Korea. By the end of this novel, the author’s research into these machinations, and some of their brutal human ramifications, including re-education camps, nearly swamps the book — the narrative begins to feel like reportage, like didactic historical exposé ... Most profound when it, too, pays attention to emotionally knotty children and young adults. Choi has a profound gift, one I find consistently moving, for making their dilemmas universal ... Choi is in thrilling command before the book’s scaffolding, supportive but ungainly, begins to assert itself over the edifice.

آخرین مدیر
ستایش

Vivid ... He takes Weaver seriously; he understands why his tenure mattered to baseball; he is alert to the details of the unruly pageant that was his life; he explains, a bit ruefully, why he was probably the last of his kind ... This biography is good from the start because Weaver’s story is ... Weaver was a flawed man, but Miller’s book is largely a paean to his ebullience.