At its best, See You on the Other Side offers the reader the chatty, undemanding companionship of commercial fiction ... McInerney doesn’t seem to have made peace with the fact that he’s turning out a potboiler and keeps offering us glimpses of more tormented and ambitious writers ... The early comparisons between Fitzgerald and McInerney now ring very hollow. Fitzgerald wrote with great precision and his vision of life was tragic, at odds with the dominant ethos of his time. McInerney’s prose is loose to the point of absurdity and he seems fully to embrace the materialism that surrounds him.
اگر بخوایم یک زندگینامه جدید از تولکین داشته باشیم، دی. جی. تیلور گزینهی فوقالعادهای برای نوشتنش میشه. او که بهخاطر نوشتن زندگینامهی جایزهدار جورج اورول شناخته شده، اعتبار نردی بینقصی هم داره. با رها شدن از قیود یک زندگینامه سنتی، تیلور بهجای اون کتابی شوخطبع، کوتاهتر و بیاحترامتر میده که زندگی تولکین رو دنبال میکنه و همزمان با رازها و تناقضهای شخصیت و دستاوردهایش دست و پنجه نرم میکنه. «King under the Mountain» که کاملاً دقیق، بینشمند و عمیقاً پژوهشمحوره، موفق میشه با لبخند به نکات عجیب و غریب و پوچیهای تولکین نگاه کنه و در عین حال به استعداد مرموز و بیچونوچراش ادای احترام کنه.
Dexterous and formally inventive ... Barrels along, effortlessly resonating with larger ideas, sustained by humour and a sharp and empathetic intelligence ... Can anyone in good conscience make fiction out of these tragic events? Though not every element of the story is equally successful – I was left puzzled by the passivity of the kidnapped bachelors – the answer to that question is resoundingly affirmative.
Timely ... There are some excellent things in this novel. The account of the journey and the observations of the work on board the ship feel as if they must be rooted in McCann’s own reportage ... I loved the thoughtful, essayistic inquiries into nature and the environment, and the consciousness-raising voyage towards the broken cable. But I have to confess that I’m not entirely in sympathy with all McCann’s aesthetic decisions ... Lingers after you’ve put it down.