Jennifer Szalai, The New York Times

  • ۱۵ نقد در چونی
صفحه‌اش در منبع
آیا رودخانه زنده است؟
دوگانه

Macfarlane is justifiably known for lush, evocative prose. But his epiphanies can be so portentous that I started to feel restless, even amid so many gorgeous Macfarlanian sentences. When he observes what he sees, his descriptions are original, sinuous and often startling; when he’s in thrall to a reverie, his descriptions get windy and sentimental ... Macfarlane weaves in plenty of factual information, including vivid passages on the biodiversity of cloud forests and the destruction caused by metal mining. But his method of persuasion isn’t primarily scientific; it’s affective and moral ... There is so much solemn virtue packed into this book I was grateful for the occasional bits of human comedy.

ماسکیسم
ستایش

Slobodian and Tarnoff skillfully guide us through ... The book brings us through the Muskian upheavals of last year, when Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency descended on federal agencies ... The account of those events is surreal, until you remember that they actually happened ... Striking.

پیشگویی
ستایش

Witty and surprising ... Lively ... Shows how Big Tech has accrued enormous amounts of wealth and power by promising insight into the future. These modern oracles claim to make us safer, but, she argues, they are doing precisely the opposite ... A book like Prophecy — roving, intelligent, irreducibly idiosyncratic — can expand our sense of possibility, starting now.

عبور از دریای رنگِ شراب
ستایش

Wonderfully spirited ... An expert in the ancient world, she nevertheless draws constantly (and productively) from contemporary culture ... Wilson elegantly braids together close, line-by-line readings with larger arguments about how much is often at stake ... You don’t even have to be particularly interested in ancient literature to enjoy this book, though by the time you finish it you probably will be. Wilson’s excitement for her subject is irrepressibly moving.

۳۸ خیابان لندن
ستایش

Marvelous and absorbing ... Inimitable ... Sands is also a consummate storyteller, gently teasing out his heavy themes and the accompanying legal intricacies through the unforgettable details he unearths and the many people...who open up to him.

سقراط باز
ستایش

این کتاب جذاب، هوشمند و گاهی اذیت‌کننده است … با وجود بعضی از اظهارات بزرگ‌نمایی‌اش، کالارد ما رو دعوت می‌کنه که همراهش فکر کنیم. Open Socrates ما رو تشویق می‌کنه که بفهمیم چقدر کم می‌دونیم و شروع به فکر کردن کنیم.

اثبات
مثبت

Useful ... Proving what is 'obvious and simple' isn’t always easy. Kucharski offers the delightful example of Muriel Bristol, a scientist who always put the milk in her cup before pouring her tea, because she insisted it tasted better.

تصادم‌ها
دوگانه

The physicist Luis Alvarez is one of those 20th-century figures whose life was so eventful that it should be catnip for a biographer ... It’s a tantalizing characterization. Just don’t get too excited ... In seeking to deflate the myth of the audacious Alvarez, [Nevala-Lee] has overcorrected, jettisoning drama and tension in favor of diligent explanation. The result is a thorough, dutiful parsing of Alvarez’s work in the laboratory and a strangely pallid portrait of the man himself ... I pulled most of these tidbits from Collisions; the morsels are there, but they’re drifting in a sea of detail. Such an emphasis might be deliberate, a willful refusal to indulge Alvarez’s self-serving self-presentation in order to focus the reader’s attention on what truly mattered: how his laboratories worked ... Bringing such a culture to life would be a challenge for any biographer. I appreciated Nevala-Lee’s careful research and his sense of obligation. But I finished the book bleary-eyed and worn out—and wanting something more.

عفو
مثبت

Toobin admirably weaves all these threads together. But what struck me most about The Pardon was how bizarrely quaint all the wrangling over Watergate seems now, compared with the onslaught of our frenzied political moment ... Toobin’s book offers little by way of consolation. Even in a democracy, “the royal prerogative of mercy” has its appeal, especially during cruel times. But as The Pardon makes exceedingly clear, it can also serve as a weapon for a leader who insists he can do whatever he wants.

پژواک آینه آب
ستایش

پُر شور و شوق … چانگ ما رو توی یک روایت پر جنب و جوش که پر از حکایات رنگارنگ، زمینه تاریخی و حاشیه‌های گفت‌وگویی می‌بره، راهنمایی می‌کنه … میراث لی فراتر از دنیای سلبریتی و سرگرمی‌هاست، چانگ می‌گوید. حتی اگه این کار کمی دور از واقعیت باشه که حضور روی صفحهٔ لی رو معادل آزادی و عدالت بگذاریم، شاید این یک شروع بود.