John Warner, The Chicago Tribune

  • ۹ نقد در چونی
صفحه‌اش در منبع
چیزهایی که هرگز نمی‌گوییم
ستایش

الیزابت استراوت یه توانایی خاص داره که باعث می‌شه با شخصیت‌هاش هم‌ذات‌پنداری کنم... نقطه قوت این کتاب توی مهارت استراوت در کالبدشکافی لحظات کوچیکیه که شخصیت‌ها رو برملا می‌کنه و بینشون پیوند می‌زنه... نتیجه‌اش تجربه‌ای از مطالعه‌ست که هم گرم و دلنشینه و هم آدم رو به‌شدت نگران می‌کنه. فکر نمی‌کنم امروز کسی باشه که بتونه به این سبک بنویسه.

نگهبانی
منفی

To say that I like George Saunders’ writing is a significant understatement ... So, it has been a source of great confusion, and even distress, to process my less-than-positive response to Saunders’ new novel, Vigil ... [A] section ends with some slapstick that is deliberately, comically juvenile, but it created, in me at least, a kind of tonal whiplash that I couldn’t quite shake ... One of the book’s themes is that judging others is easy, but understanding is hard, a theme infused in Saunders’ oeuvre over the years. But in this moment, in this story, I could not wholly abide it. I think some of this is in the uneven execution of the difficult problem Saunders gave himself with this book. But surely some of it is also found inside of me and my present view of the world that Saunders is trying to illuminate.

بی‌نظیر
ستایش

One of the more enjoyable reading experiences I’ve had in a while ... A novel about ordinary people during war, a supernatural time travel story, and also a romance of sorts ... I will admit that I personally found some of the supernatural action sequences a little dull — though this is a me problem — and Iris occasionally seems more two-dimensional than three-dimensional, complicated but not surprising. But these things did not hinder my enjoyment of Spufford’s storytelling.

ملایم باش
ستایش

Some of what unfolds perhaps strains the limits of believability if you pause to consider the sequence of events, but don’t pause, just keep going ... Go Gentle is a fun, rollicking read, but it’s not only that. It’s a moving portrait of an interesting person that may also make you reflect on yourself.

پناهگاه
مثبت

An exploration of power dynamics, surveillance, colonialism, toxic masculinity, and other big concepts. We seem to be getting clues from the island’s inhabitants, but maybe they just enjoy messing with the outsiders who have invaded their territory. I was desperate to learn Gabriel’s fate, but could not put together how the things we were being shown were drawing us closer to a conclusion. The novel’s scope seemed to expand just as I was expecting it to narrow. No spoilers here, but the resolution is not easy or straightforward. Some of what’s been hidden is revealed, but much remains mysterious, at least to me. To me, it felt both true to the project and, to a degree, unsatisfying, but this seems to be the point. We can’t expect tidy resolutions.

زیر آبشار
منفی

I have read all 10 of Richard Russo’s novels and all four of his short story collections. I would recommend them to any reader, any time. So, please believe me when I say that I was befuddled when reading Russo’s new novel, Under the Falls, and experienced a creeping sense of disconnection and dissatisfaction ... This other book simply did not work for me. It jettisoned everything I thought was coming for something else. Even as I adjusted to what the book was attempting, it all felt at odds with Russo’s amazing gift for character interiority grounded in place.

فاشیسم زمان‌های آخر
ستایش

End Times Fascism does indeed tell a scary story, but I finished the book feeling not scared, but hopeful that we’re already managing these threats, and more progress is possible going forward ... It is all very grim, but Taylor and Klein want us to recognize that there is not only hope, but tangible progress ... A bracing, vital read.

آتش کهنه
ستایش

For a book that took only a few hours of reading time, it has managed to remain in my thoughts in the weeks since I first read it ... The prose is spare, unadorned ... Quiet, and devastating ... Moments accrue bit by bit ... A book that requires a particular kind of attention, a willingness to still and let the perspective of another move through you.

نظریه فریب
ستایش

Occasionally, you will encounter a book that seems custom-made for you. Emily Adrian’s Seduction Theory is that kind of book ... A plot that unfolds with clear, character-motivated logic that also manages to surprise and keep you wondering how things might end ... Funny ... I felt for all these people by the end, while also finding great comedy in their many foibles ... I also read Seduction Theory in a single sitting, perhaps proving the accuracy of its title.