A wide-ranging feat of reporting ... Macfarlane introduces us not only to the rivers in these singular parts of the world but also to the environmentalists trying to save them, as well as the novel philosophical program that unites these efforts ... Vivid, sometimes even flowery ... Not just informative but frequently beautiful, full of luscious lines ... Unfortunately, Macfarlane is also prone to overwriting and the kind of breathless observations that strike people on drugs as profound ... As it so often does, the sentimentality of the writing reflects a certain sentimentality of thought.
Wade’s superb new book...is the biography of both a woman and a reputation. The biography of the woman has been written several times already, though perhaps never so stylishly. The biography of the reputation is in large part fresh. Both are a pleasure to read ... Wade has a sense for character and an eye for detail, and in the first part of Gertrude Stein, she paints a vivid portrait of her striving, grasping subject ... The revelations in Gertrude Stein are exciting, but perhaps even more gripping are the characters the book brings so vividly to life.
Absorbing ... His memoir is less an indictment of home schooling in general than a vivid portrait of the way the practice failed one child in particular. Block makes brief note of the regulatory vacuum that allowed his predicament, but for the most part he writes with the phenomenological precision and narrative verve of a novelist ... It is fitting that Homeschooled is narrated in the present tense. Evidently, Block’s childhood memories are still possessed of a sharp immediacy. The past is never really over for someone subjected to such scarring humiliations during his formative years.
An unwieldy book with three disparate threads, each focussed on a different character ... Despite her reputation for rigor, Life of M is not a disciplined dismantling; it is discombobulated and haphazard, a machine breaking down at random ... At times, Life of M threatens to become a book composed entirely of vacuities ... In Life of M, there is even less of a filter between the characters’ perspectives and that of the book ... There is something at once magisterial and leadenly self-regarding about the melancholic rhythms of Cusk’s prose, with its stiff and stately syntax and its utter impatience with the real vagaries of difference.
Wan and blinkered ... All too often reads like a hammer in search of a nail ... He tries to enfold even unwieldy and sprawling truths into his cramped formal apparatus ... The problem is not that he has a penchant for summarizing thought experiments…but that he cannot provide a convincing account of what the puzzles he loves have to do with the world ... This is the kind of public intellectualism that makes the public hate intellectuals.
In his excellent new book, Plato and the Tyrant: The Fall of Greece’s Greatest Dynasty and the Making of a Philosophic Masterpiece, the classicist James Romm brings Plato down to earth ... A deft and engaging work of history, philosophy and biography, as well as a meta-commentary on the perils of regarding canonical thinkers as disembodied minds ... Plato and the Tyrant is full of something that I do not readily associate with the distinguished poster child of Western philosophy: gossip and intrigue. The story of Plato’s stint in Syracuse is as rife with human interest as any melodrama ... Romm relates this history—and introduces readers to a colorful cast of sycophantic courtiers, eccentric philosophers and defiant poets—with flair. He is an equally admirable guide to the many controversies in which the affair is mired ... Nowhere is he more in his element than when he wades into the vicious, centuries-long conflict over the authorship of the 13 'Platonic' letters.
Baker’s thesis is rousingly novel and ingeniously fine-grained ... Not dry, insular or detached from everyday concerns. Although it is thoroughly researched and rigorously conceived, it is also gripping. This is history with urgent stakes and real consequences.
Contains a smattering of memoir and hefty doses of cognitive science, but it is primarily a work of philosophy ... Rowlands’s book is...as much an inquiry into the nature of humanity as it is a celebration of dogs and their virtues. It does not, however, paint a very flattering portrait of dogs’ handlers ... Sometimes, The Word of Dog is a bit in the weeds, which I mean as a compliment. Rowlands is at his best when he refrains from simplifying or sugarcoating and dives headfirst into some of the thorniest arguments in the history of philosophy.
Leman led a life so rich in incident that only a novel could do justice to its complexities, and a novel, of sorts, is exactly what Ypi has written ... An inward-looking rumination but a desperate attempt to conjure a bygone milieu — and a fitting rejoinder to the tendencies it wishes to contradict ... Ypi displays a certain audacity as she sets about reconstructing a world she never witnessed, but she is no more presumptuous than the files she is working from ... Remarkable and ambitious.
برنرز‑لی اینقدر خوشمشرب و عمومانند بهعنوان راوی هست که تقریباً وسوسه میشم که بهش باور کنم … تصمیم برنرز‑لی برای عمومی کردن وب کاملاً به سبک خودش بود؛ تو تمام دوران کاریاش یک آدم خوب و بااخلاق بوده … خیلی کمتر از اکثر کتابهای ترویجگرهای تکنولوژی اذیتکنندهست … راهحلهای پیشنهادی برنرز‑لی، هرچند امیدوارکننده، به نظر ناکافی میرسن.