بررسی تنهایی و تلاش برای پیدا کردن معنا در حومهی شهرهای آمریکا... کتاب «چیزهایی که هرگز نمیگوییم» جزئی از مجموعهرمانهای الیزابت استراوت دربارهی اولیو کیتریج یا لوسی بارتون نیست، اما از نظر سبک شباهت زیادی به اونها داره: ساده، صادقانه و بیزار از هرگونه تزیینات ادبی... بعضی وقتها استراوت وسوسه میشه که روایت رو قطع کنه و یه سری اظهارنظر قلبی دربارهی بشریت بکنه... یه زاویهی سیاسیِ پُر از احساس هم توی کتاب هست که از قبل از انتخابات ریاستجمهوری ۲۰۲۴ شروع میشه و توی یه اپیلوگ هشداردهنده، به آیندهی ما میرسه. این پرداختن به مسائل روز، هرچند همدلانه است، اما یه جورایی وصلهی ناجور به نظر میرسه. استراوت مهارت واقعی خودش رو در قالبهای کهنالگویی پیدا کرده و داستانهایی مینویسه که شبیه تمثیلهای غیرمذهبی یا درامهای اخلاقیِ مردمی هستن.
به طرز لذتبخشی زده به سرش... مدلین کش بحرانهای خانوادگی رو با ترکیب برنده و جذابی از کمدی سیاه و شیرینیِ معصومانه روایت میکنه... داستانی گیرا و تا حدی کارتونیه که استعداد خانم کش در خلق دیالوگهای تند و تیز و شخصیتهای عجیب و دوستداشتنی رو به رخ میکشه. این هم کمک کرده که معلوم باشه خود نویسنده موقع نوشتن حسابی کیف کرده.
The characters may well be good people—certainly that is how Ms. Patchett means to portray them—but their goodness is never put to any test, so it exists as nothing more than an affirming idea ... Goodness seems like too active a word for this novel; the principal virtue, instead, is solicitude. These characters are models of consideration, and Ms. Patchett has fashioned a writing style that follows their example ... I get the sense that this optimistic, relentlessly nice novel intends to provide some pleasantness during a hard time. This may seem admirable, but only if you ignore that you’re being treated like a 9-year-old.
Sensitive ... The depiction of family solidarity in the face of hardship is touching, and to Ms. Lee’s credit she portrays it simply, without smarminess ... Has the drawbacks of the traditional novel along with its foursquare virtues. The book’s length and creeping pace are reminiscent of 19th-century tomes that had to be padded out to meet the requirements of serialization. Ms. Lee tends to telegraph her plot turns, especially those regarding the characters’ romantic fortunes, and then takes an eternity to arrive where the story is obviously going ... The danger of dullness is heightened by the writing, which is plain and informational to an extreme ... he polite reviewerese for this kind of writing is 'workmanlike,' and it often feels like work to get through it ... That there is still much to like about the novel speaks to the charm of its earnest exploration of virtue ... Heartfelt.
The reasons for John’s ferocious emotional repression are not fully explored, but they seem intrinsic to his grimly sustaining notion of island heritage. To accept his nature would be to abandon a sense of identity as traditional as the man-powered loom. As John of John unspools the lies and fights in the torturous father-son relationship, it captures the stark, workaday rhythms of the island ... Relief is found in the moments of fellowship and natural splendor that are threaded into the story like strands of bright yarn ... Even so, the feeling of captivity is onerous in John of John ... The author wields his powers of compassion to enlarge the characters of John and Cal, but these are grown men who merely behave like children—John is a bully, Cal is a brat—and it is harder to submit to their struggles.
Breezy ... As the novel zips along—there are lively depictions of the Blitz, plenty of sex and a rom-com’s worth of flirtatious patter—Mr. Spufford’s reasons for withholding information about the science-fiction conceit become clearer.
A story whose very premise ensures that little can happen poses a narrative challenge. Ms. Clark stages smart, probing explorations of an upbringing marked by waiting and repetition, in which the notion of growth appears fictitious ... There are points when the novel seems, like its characters, to be merely doing time. But not always. Ms. Clark imbues Hillcrest with eerie metaphoric resonance, making it both forbidding and tenderly familiar ... A plot twist near the end rewards much of the reader’s patience; after so much standstill, the sudden change strikes Suzanna—and us—like a blow to the chest.
Evokes an intimate, sometimes smothering feeling of presentness ... The writing is piercing and suspenseful, and Ms. Cline deserves praise for engraving a style recognizably her own ... All surface, lacking the interiority and character development that provide immersion and depth ... The book powerfully constricts as it nears the final appointment, describing a terrible itinerary of last things—David’s last meal, his last change of clothing, his last bit of paperwork. Ms. Cline recounts it all without looking away.
A finely observed and highly oblique portrayal of London bohemians. It is a book that leads with its rigorously achieved style, which is stripped down, dryly unsentimental and keenly attuned to the tensions present in families and friendships ... Evokes fragile feelings of vulnerability and longing among her characters, while gesturing toward a potential for contentedness in community and intellectual integrity ... What I missed amid the novel’s deft personality critiques was precisely what Laura sees in her friends ... In this talented author’s relentless paring back, too many interesting things have been cut away.
Beautifully captured ... Ms. Riley’s novel is a wonderful, loving, tenderly teasing and often moving portrait ... Ms. Riley achieves a balance of warmth and subtle hilarity ... Her depiction of the Hutterites is affectionate and normalizing, though far from sentimental ... Standout.
The unrelentingly raw and profane vision is enlivened by the energy of the writing, and in particular its infusions of Jamaican slang ... Suggests an emotional urgency to the material, which may explain why the writing feels so despairing and disorderly—and why the ending, which I think is meant to represent a startling culmination of events, seems merely tacked on. However difficult the novel’s pain and desperation may be to endure, though, they leave a mark on the memory.
A sprawling, mural-like novel ... Has the action in Crucible been spread too thin? I think so ... Which is not to say that Crucible lacks great moments or a dynamic vision of American history.
The feeling of vibrancy owes in large part to Griffin’s narration, which is wised-up yet cheerfully innocent ... Lavishly detailed ... A weakness for symbolism accounts for the thinness of other parts ... The novel’s pleasantly noodling pace picks up toward the end, when Naomi reappears with far more predatory designs. Another mark of the book’s freshness is that, even though it contains all the ingredients for a mopey story of formative traumas, Playworld never sheds its winsome optimism.
Downbeat and irreverent, Mr. deWitt’s road-trip novel glances at, though never lingers over, themes of responsibility, abandonment and agency. It throws in a touching consolation at the ending, too, so it isn’t only bad vibes.
Accomplished ... Sabit skillfully inhabits the voices of Rahmat’s acquaintances in the Afghan community, his Virginia neighbors and the eyewitnesses of events leading up to Zorah’s demise. The composite picture is contradictory, reflecting the complexities of a family living the American dream but still tied to the customs of their people and their faith ... Since we are not privy to the perspectives of any of the Sharafs, there is a somewhat frustrating hole at the center of Good People. This intelligent novel is instead interested in the effects of gossip, bias and assumptions, and the ways that a single set of facts can be used to construct completely different conclusions.
Goodman finds the right measure of sugar in this novel-in-stories ... Mines excellent, bone-dry humor from the neuroses ... Goodman’s mature and deftly written book suggests that, in family as in art, there is no such thing as uncomplicated happiness.
Mr. Hanif has struggled to rebottle the lightning of his brilliant 2008 satire, A Case of Exploding Mangoes ... Rebel English Academy reprises the excoriating humor of that debut, but only erratically.
The story unfolds in the episodic fashion of television dramas, ticking off topical conflicts such as the pandemic, the Black Lives Matter protests and the #MeToo movement as they bear upon the Calloways and their daughter, Storey, who is opening a Brooklyn bistro at the worst possible moment ... All this will be to your tastes or not, but credit Mr. McInerney with not being self-important about his material ... Mr. McInerney had his turn as a celebrated literary arriviste. Now he’s enjoying himself.
Somber ... This austere, tamped-down novel is frustratingly committed to silence. Passions still smolder below the surface, but there is not enough oxygen to let them flame into life.
Strikingly, Ghost-Eye has none of the eerie mood of a Gothic novel or ghost story. This is because the book treats reincarnation not as an ambiguous phenomenon but an empirical fact. ... The strangeness of Ghost-Eye will keep readers on their toes, but the book’s earnest, scientific framework makes it seem like an elaborate exercise in wishful thinking.
Neglects fictional elements such as story, character and setting in favor of tendentious conceptual musings about power and freedom and the like. Ms. Cusk’s signal strength is her spotless, epigrammatic prose ... I wondered whether Ms. Cusk would prefer to write a book like that—a collection of aphorisms, perhaps, in which nothing would stand between the reader and the author’s mandarin profundities.
The writing is clever, coolly stylized and, alas, deathly boring ... Historical uncertainty is an intriguing theme, but less so when it’s achieved through vagueness.
The women’s relationship is honest and nurturing, and Ms. Orringer portrays it with great sensitivity. Elsewhere, she is less generous. Barr comes off as a caricature of the 'great male narcissists' ... Yet the star of the book is not human at all, but an injured rescue dog, Luna, whom a few of the characters befriend ... Touching.
Overwrought but arresting, the drama relies upon the immediacy of Ms. McBride’s prose, in which fractious, vibratory sentences communicate the shorthand of Eily’s agitated thoughts ... You submit to the soap opera of the story for the sensitivity of the style, which, like an emotional seismograph, registers every nuance of fondness and fear.
Satisfyingly layered ... Excellent ... In part an episodic family saga structured by the passage of time rather than the pressures of a story arc ... That Ms. Choi manages these swerving, even outlandish, dramatic twists without flattening her characters is this novel’s outstanding achievement. Flashlight investigates secrecy and coverups on the private, psychological plane and on the level of international intrigue.
Impressively, A Private Man is sensuous but never salacious ... The ecstasies of attraction are sublimated into their long conversations about Boethius and Hildegard von Bingen, or about the suddenly debatable issues of contraception and clerical celibacy ... Those two qualities—gravity and passion—characterize this standout debut.
In his sensitive and cheerfully unrushed fashion, Mr. Gurnah advances the trajectories of the trio to explore the mutable nature of family ... Fruitfully explores the meanings of work and love from Karim’s and Badar’s different points of view. The novel is also attuned to the influence of Tanzania’s political evolution on the characters’ private lives ... Each of these subjects is richly developed in the novel, though none is prioritized, so that it’s possible to read far into this book, find it entirely engrossing and yet not really know what Mr. Gurnah means to say with it.
Haslett sets up this story with a delicacy that will not surprise anyone who read his beautiful 2016 novel ... But Mothers and Sons abandons much that makes it original as it settles into the familiar mold of the trauma narrative, in which a terrible, all-explanatory past event is revealed, leading to the damaged character’s recovery.
The style of these stories is akin to surrealism, with all the attendant pleasures and irritations ... Is the story sincere? Is it satirical? Its charm lies in its ability to leave such questions intriguingly unresolved.
Mr. Nadler develops this melancholy notion with care and solemnity, stripping from his writing anything that might distract from its elegiac tone ... There is a stark, unfurnished quality to Rooms for Vanishing that makes its protracted length difficult to bear. The novel has the beauty of a dirge but not the substance of a story.
Messy, fascinating ... The collision of fiction with nonfiction is mirrored by the constant tonal swerves. Scenes oscillate between the macabre and the sentimental, the ridiculous and the sincere. Whatever response to the invasion you can imagine, Ms. Reva likely has it covered ... None of it holds together, but the results are entertainingly shambolic.
It’s chewy material, or at least it would be if Mr. McCann had resisted the impulse to poeticize it into total abstraction ... The ingratiating first-person plural...attempts a connection with the reader that the constant dorm-room philosophizing can’t sustain.